Welcome! I really enjoy exchanging information with people and love that this blog helps with that. I consider much of my research as a work in progress, so please let me know if you have conflicting information. Some of the surnames I'm researching:

Many old Cape families including Kelley, Eldredge/idge, Howes, Baker, Mayo, Bangs, Snow, Chase, Ryder/Rider, Freeman, Cole, Sears, Wixon, Nickerson.
Many old Plymouth County families including Washburn, Bumpus, Lucas, Cobb, Benson.
Johnson (England to MA)
Corey (Correia?) (Azores to MA)
Booth, Jones, Taylor, Heatherington (N. Ireland to Quebec)
O'Connor (Ireland to MA)
My male Mayflower ancestors (only first two have been submitted/approved by the Mayflower Society):
Francis Cooke, William Brewster, George Soule, Isaac Allerton, John Billington, Richard Warren, Peter Browne, Francis Eaton, Samuel Fuller, James Chilton, John Tilley, Stephen Hopkins, and John Howland.
Female Mayflower ancestors: Mary Norris Allerton, Eleanor Billington, Mary Brewster, Mrs. James Chilton, Sarah Eaton, and Joan Hurst Tilley.
Child Mayflower ancestors: Giles Hopkins, (possibly) Constance Hopkins, Mary Allerton, Francis Billington, Love Brewster, Mary Chilton, Samuel Eaton, and Elizabeth Tilley.

Sunday, November 22, 2026

Thomas Bourne (ca 1581 to May 1664) of England, and Plymouth & Marshfield, Mass., and his Wife Elizabeth

Thomas Bourne was born about 1581 [based on age at death] in England. I am unsure of his origins, although there are some theories I need to explore including that he was from Kent. He was in his 50s when he immigrated circa 1636 to Plymouth Colony. Thomas was immediately referred to with the honorific “Mr” in colony records and in one instance as gentleman, indicating the prominent standing he held in the community. His name is sometimes spelled Burne and Bourn in records. He is my 11th great-grandfather on my grandfather Arthur Washburn Ellis Davis’ side of the family.

Thomas was briefly at Plymouth before leaving for Green Harbor (later named Marshfield) where as one of the original settlers he received a huge land grant of 100 acres. Early on, the town was sometimes referred to as Rexhame.


His home was a garrison, a fortified building where neighbors would go for protection when there was a threat of Indian attack. At town meeting on 27 September 1643, it was agreed that because of eminent danger posed by Indians, there was to be a constant watch at four houses, including that of Mr Thomas Burne’s where Josiah Winslow was to be in charge. [The Mayflower Descendant, hereafter MD,  62:29 and DeForest]


The Bourne property was on a neck of land, separated from nearby upland by a broad tidal creek and marsh, but the beach offered protection from Indian attack and there was excellent fishing in both river and sea. Only a handful of settlers lived on the neck, and some were on 100 acre land grants, so it must have been very isolated. In the circa 1644 list of freemen in Plymouth Colony, only 11 men lived in all of Marshfield. [NEHGS Register 7:276] In 1636 a canal was ordered to be expanded to 18 feet wide and six feet wide, from North Plymouth to Green’s Harbor which then connected toward South River and Scituate. It was first created ca 1626 to reduce the loss of ships and crews and was later called Cut River or Break Through. It is said to be America’s first canal. [AmericanCanalSociety.org] 


Thomas Bourne married, in England, Elizabeth whose maiden name is unknown. She was born about 1590 based on age at death. Elizabeth and Thomas had five known children born in England (approximate birth years from Jacobus):

  1. Martha born say 1614; married 1st by 1650 John Bradford son of Mayflower passengers Governor William and Dorothy (May) Bradford; removed to Norwich CT; married 2nd Thomas Tracy about 1679; died between 1680-1683 probably at Norwich [Wakefield & Lainhart]; she did not have children and brought her nephew Thomas Waterman to Norwich and left him one-third of her estate [Jacobus]
  2. Margaret born say 1616; married Josiah/Josias Winslow brother of Governor Edward Winslow; she was buried Marshfield 2 Oct 1683 [Jacobus]
  3. Elizabeth born say 1618; married 1st 11 Dec 1638 Robert Waterman who died 10 Dec 1652; married 2nd in 1653 Thomas Tilden son of Nathaniel and Lydia Tilden; she was buried Marshfield 12 Dec 1663 [Marshfield VR 1:10]
  4. Anne born say 1620; married 21 Jan 1639/40 Nehemiah Smith/Smyth [Plymouth VR p 654]; removed to Norwich CT; died after 12 Jan 1684 when she is mentioned in a document [Jacobus]
  5. John born say 1622; married Marshfield 18 July 1645 Alice Besbedge (later Bisbee) [Marshfield VR p 1] who was born in Kent, daughter of Thomas and Anne (Baseden) Besbedge; John was constable, Deputy to the Court, Selectman, and magistrate; he was buried 8 Dec 1684 [Marshfield VR p 6]

I descend from Elizabeth. I wrote about her here and here. Thomas was generous to Elizabeth and her husband Robert—on 11 January 1652/3 he paid off the cost of real estate Robert bought of Edmond Weston. [DeForest]


Given the isolated, sparsely populated area in which they lived, it is not surprising that two of Thomas and Elizabeth’s daughters married neighbors: Margaret to Josiah Winslow, brother of Governor Winslow and Elizabeth to Robert Waterman. The marriages of two of his daughters to brothers or sons of governors show the prominent social and political circles in which Thomas belonged. 


John inherited the homestead and it passed to succeeding generations, including John Bourne who fought at Bunker Hill during the Revolutionary War. [Krusell & Bates] The house, which has been enlarged, remarkably still stands at 1308 Ocean Street. [Marshfield Historical Commission House Survey]  Krusell and Bates' book has a map of Rexhame Village indicating early settlers' homestead locations, which I dont have permission to include here. 


Thomas Bourne House in Marshfield (source: Google Maps Street View)

On 7 March 1636/7 Mr Thomas Burne was listed among freemen of the colony, but he wasn’t sworn and admitted as freeman until 2 January 1637/8. [Records of Colony of New Plymouth, hereafter PCR, 1:53; 74] 


Thomas served his community in a variety of ways:

  • Appointed as Deputy to the General Court representing Marshfield (which was incorporated in 1640) on June 1641 (representing Rexhame), June 1642, Oct 1645. [PCR 2:16, 2:40, 94]
  • 5 June 1638 Richard Burne was one of 16 “honest and lawfull men of the colony” to make oath that they viewed the body of John England, found dead upon the flats of the Plymouth shore. He was sailing a canoe belonging to Mr. Thomas Burnes betwixt Greenes Harbor and Plymouth, the canoe was insufficient to make way in stormy weather and was over set, and John England was drowned. The canoe was the cause of the death and should be forfeited to our sovereign Lord the Kinge, apprised at 10 shillings sterling, and committed to the keeping of the government of New Plymouth. [PCR 1:88]
  • Served on a variety of juries. One example is 2 January 1637/8 when the jury found William Corvannell guilty of theft and sentenced him to be whipped and burned on the shoulder with a hot iron. [PCR 1:49, 74, 2:16, 40, 94, 115, 124, 134; 7:12]  
  • “Thomas Burne, gent.,” served on grand inquest, 5 June 1638 [PCR 1:87], 7 June 1648. [PCR 2:124]
  • Mr Thomas Burne of Marshfield is on the 1643 list of men able to bear arms. [DeForest]
  • At 19 August 1645 town meeting, eleven men pledged money to support a teacher’s salary beyond what they would pay for their own children’s educations to start the town’s first public school. Although his own children were adults, Thomas Burne pledged 10s. His son John Burne and son-in-law Robert Waterman each pledged the same amount. [Richards]
  • At 16 Feb 1645/6 town meeting, Mr Thomas Burne was chosen moderator. [MD 62:139]
  • 2 June 1646 the court ordered that Mr Thomas Willet, Mr John Alden, Mr Thomas Bourne, Thomas Chambers, Thomas Tupper, Henry Andrewes, Anthony Annable, Edmond Hawes & Steeven Payne, shall as a committee, consider a way for defraying the charges of the magistrates table, by way of excise upon wine & other things. [PCR 2:101]
  • On 30 March 1645/6 Mr Thomas Burns was one of five men appointed to lay out highways “both horse & foote” and on 1 June 1647 Thomas Bourne and Thomas Tylden appointed supervisors of the highways for Marshfield. [MD 62:140, PCR 2:115]
  • 4 Oct 1648 Mr Thomas Burne served on the grand inquest of the case of Allice Bishope, wife of Richard Bishope, of New Plymouth, who was indicted for felonious murder of Martha Clark, “her owne child, the frute of her own body. “ A petit jury of different men found her guilty of murder and sentenced her to be hanged. [PCR 2:134]
  • Presentments by the Grand Enquest 2 March 1651, “Wee present Jonathan Coventrey of the towne of Marshfield, for making a motion of marriage unto Katheren Bradberey, servant unto Mr Burne, of the same towne, without her masters consent, contrary to Court order.” [PCR 3:5]
  • He was named one of the town’s raters, men who assessed and collected taxes, in 1643, 1645, and 1652. [MD 61:31, MD 62:139, 63:115]
  • At 3 Nov 1656 Town Meeting, Mr Thomas Bourne and Joseph Beedell were to receive the £10 which Mr Edward Winslow bequeathed to the poor of the town and were to be “betrusted” with its expenditure. [MD 4:2]
  • At a 1663 town meeting some residents contributed toward the relief of Edward Bumpus, supplying him with bushels of corn. Mr Bourne gave one bushel. [Richards p 49]
  • 5 June 1666 granted by the Court that Ensign Barnard Lumbard, John Finney, and Isacke Robinson be supplied with 50 acres apiece or more of upland at Pausatuke Necke or thereabouts, with six acres of meadow left to the discretion of Mr Hinckley and Mr Bacon to view, purchase, and lay out unto them; Mr Bourne also being added to them, to be helpful therein. [PCR 4:128]
  • He was a church deacon. [DeForest]
  • He frequently witnessed wills and other documents of his neighbors.

Land transactions involving Thomas Bourne:

  • On 2 Jan 1636/7 land granted to “Josiah Winslow, Richard Burne, and to John Burne, on the behalf of his father Mr Thomas Burne, & to James Coale, seven acres apiece, to belong to their dwelling houses in Plymouth, and not to be sold from them, but when such dwellings shall be void, to return unto the town to be disposed of to others.” [PCR 1:49]
  • On 4 December 1637, 100 acres of land granted to Mr. Thomas Burne, lying at Greene’s Harbor, upon condition that the said farm shall belong to the town of Plymouth and to pay his portion of such charges as may accidentally fall upon it for the purchase thereof, wch said lands are to be viewed and laid forth for him from his house to the seaward. A garden place also in Plymouth to build upon is also granted unto the said Mr. Thomas Burne. [PCR 1:70] 
  • On 8 March 1637[/?8] John Winslow of Plymouth “doth acknowledge that he hath sold a house and a garden place scituate in the New street in Plymouth aforesd to Mr Thomas Burne for the sum of sixteene pounds sterling to him in hand payd to have and to hold the said house and garden place and all and singular appurtenances thereunto belonging unto the said Thomas Burne his heirs and assigns forever to the only proper use and behoofe of the said Thomas Burne his heirs and assigns forever.” [PCR 12:28]
  • On 4 Feb 1638/9 concerning the difference about the measure of land betwixt Mr. Thomas Burne, Josias Winslow, Kenelme Winslow, and Love Brewster will be at the charge to remeasure the same, then allowed Mr. Burne and Josias Winslow their 100 acres apiece, and Kenelme and Love to have the surplusage of the said neck according to their grant. A group of men were appointed to set the bounds betwixt them. [PCR 1:111] 
  • On 2 November 1640 George Soule granted meddow he desires against Mr Prince’s land at Green’s Harbor, if in case Mr Howland do not exchange five acres with Mr Bradford, and Mr Bradford take his further of it fit him with all, or make exchange with Mr Burne & Mrs Fuller, whereby he may be furnished. [PCR 1:165]
  • On 14 February 1643/4 the town allowed marsh and meadow to Mr Thomas Burne south of land to Greene’s Harbor River and the ungranted marsh between his land and Mr Thomas Prence’s. [MD 61:125]
  • On 14 July 1649 Mr Thomas Burne acknowledged he sold unto Thomas Chillingsworth all the upland & meadow ground on the north side of the South River which he bought of Edmund Hawes, for fifty schillings to be paid to the said Thomas Burne which he received on the 19 of ye 4th month 1655. At the same time Mrs Elizabeth Bourne acknowledged her free consent to the sale of land before. [MD 63:19-20]
  • On 3 February 1652/3 Thomas Bourne of Marshfield paid £3 15s for house, land, and meadow Robert Waterman had purchased from Edmond Weston, essentially paying off his son-in-law’s mortgage. [MD 2:95]
  • On 4 May 1655 an agreement was reached between John Howland Sr, Thomas Bourne, and John Dingley concerning a difference over a parcel of Marshfield marsh and meadow that ran from the beach to Bass Creek. [MD 10:72-3]
  • On 1 June 1658 George Soule, Constant Southworth, and Phillip Delanoe were appointed by the Court to set the range betwixt Mr Bourne’s and Anthony Snow’s lands at Marshfield, to run the line on the same point of the compass that Mr Bourne’s range now runs to the South River. [PCR 3:138-9]
  • A 2 April 1659 deed from Native Americans Ussamequen Wamsutta and Tatapanum sold a large amount of land at Taunton to a large group of men including Thomas Bourne. [MD 39:147]
  • On 11 December 1662 an agreement betwixt Mr Thomas Bourne and Mr Josias Winslow was confirmed concerning the property line between their land at the South River. Interesting that he had a disagreement with his son-in-law over their land. [MD 62:29]

Thomas was minimally involved in court cases considering the litigious times:

  • At court on 7 December 1641, Mr Thomas Burne complains against James Luxford &c. The jury prized the goods against the said Luxford. [PCR 7:27]
  • At 7 June 1642 court, Mr Thomas Burne had judgment against John Chaundler for seven shillings and six pence. [PCR 2:42]
  • On 5 March 1643/4 John Mynard complains against Thomas Burne, Kenelme Winslow, and Josias Winslow, in an action of trespass upon the case, to the damage of £20. The jury find that his £20 be fully payd him, and five shilling damage & costs & charges of the suit. Execution made out for £3 8s 7 1/2 d debt, 10s 6d charges, 5s damage, & 7s 6d the execution. [PCR 7:36]
  • On 5 March 1660/1 “a blacke horse was cryed att this Court,” which was the horse which was in controversy betwixt Trustrum Hull and Mr Thomas Bourne. Referred to the Court of Assistants to be holden in May next, to be fulled ended. Column note: Ten shillings allowed to Trustrum Hull for charges of attendance about this horse. [PCR 3:208, 7:99]
  • On 4 June 1661 ordered by the court that those formerly appointed to settle the bounds betwixt Mr Bournes land and Anthony Snowes land shall also settle the outward bounds thereof. [PCR 3:217]
  • At 1 June 1663  court, in answer unto a petition preferred to the Court by Mr Thomas Bourne, of Marshfield, “concerning a horse he layed claime unto, the Court have left the case relating to that controversy as they found it, and see noe light to act further in it.” [PCR 4:43]

Thomas was of the economic status to afford servants. Jonathan Coventry was brought to court on 2 March 1651 for asking Katheren Bradberey to marry him without the consent of her master Mr Burne. [PCR 3:5] On 9 November 1643 William Launders’ indenture was transferred for £12 from Mr William Thomas to Thomas Bourne. [PCR 2:66] It’s interesting that William was more than a servant to the family.  In his 19 December 1648 will, William gave to the children of Robert Waterman “my friend” one cow and named his two friends Mr Thomas Bourne and Robert Waterman his executors. His 1 January 1648/9 inventory showed that he owed Robert Waterman “for Diet and a hogshead,” the latter being a large barrel used for shipping of liquids and dry goods. [MD 9:82-3]


Elizabeth Bourne died in July 1660. She was buried at Green Harbor on 18 July 1660, aged 70. 


Thomas Bourne, draper of Marshfield, “growed in years and weakened of body yet of good memory,” made his will 2 May 1664. [Plymouth Colony Probate Records 1:28] He left the following bequests:

  • Daughter [Martha] Bradford according to my promise twenty pounds to bee payed her in Corne or Cattle or goods; and also I give her my wifes gould Ringe
  • Daughter [Ann] Smith nine pounds to bee payed her for a legacy in Corne Cattle or goods
  • Daughter [Margaret] Winslow two cowes
  • Sonne [should be grandson] Tildin five shillings in Corne for a legacye
  • Daughter Tilden: And I give unto my Daughter Lydia Tildin forty shillings; two pounds in Cattle; for the better understand of the forty shillings [likely should read daughter Tilden’s daughter Lydia Tilden]
  • [Grandson] John Waterman two pounds in Cattle or goods or corne
  • [Grandson] Thomas Waterman two pounds in Cattle goods or corne 
  • [Grandson] Joseph Waterman two pounds in Cattle goods or Corne 
  • [Grandson] Robert Waterman two pounds in Cattle goods or Corne
  • Mr. Arnold twenty shillings in goods or Corne [likely Rev. Samuel Arnold]
  • I Doe heerby Declare my son John Bourne to bee my heire and I Doe give unto him all my lands and housing that are upon my lands that is neare hand or ruther Remote layed out or to bee layed out to mee; John named executor

Witnesses: Samuel Arnold and Anthony Snow


Inventory was taken by Sergeant Joseph Beadle, Anthony Snow, and Thomas Doged and was exhibited at court at Plymouth on 9 June 1664 on the oath of John Bourne. The real estate was "his house and land and orchyard and meddows" and "a lott of land lying neare Taunton" but the value of his land was not stated. The personal items in his inventory are difficult to read but totaled a value of over £138. Some items are livestock including oxen, bull, swine, heifer, horse; various household items; and books. 


Beneath the inventory is a list of debts due the estate totaling £9 18 8: Sergeant Cotten £6 18 9; John Branch £1 10 7; Mr Josias Winslow Senr 00 07 7; Captain Thomas 00 05 9; John Thomas 00 03 6; Mr John Bradford 00 06 3. 


Only two debts were owed from the estate: 

“for sugar and wine and fruit” for the burial £1 1s

To Humphrey Johnson 00 04 00


Thomas died in May 1664. “Mr Thomas Bourn dyed & was buried ye 11 of may 1664 at Marshfield being then aged 83.” [Marshfield VR p 10]


There is a memorial stone to Thomas and Elizabeth and other early Green Harbor settlers at Old Winslow Cemetery, Marshfield. 


Monument at Old Winslow Cemetery

Notes: I have not found proof of a familial connection between Thomas and his contemporary Richard Bourne of Sandwich, my 10th great-grandfather. Richard Bourne/Burne was Deputy to the Court for Sandwich in some of the same years as Thomas: 1641, 1642, 1645. [PCR 2:16, 40, 94] He, as Richard Burne, received a Plymouth land grant on 2 January 1636/7, the same day Mr Thomas Burne secured one for his son John. [PCR 1:49] There was also a Henry Bourne of Barnstable, but again I am uncertain if there is a connection.

Some have assigned a second wife, Martha, to Thomas, but I have not found any indication of this marriage. 


Sources:


Nathaniel B. Shurtleff and David Pulsifer, eds., Records of the Colony of New Plymouth, in New England, 12 vols. (New York: AMS Press, 1968)

Louis Effingham DeForest, Moore and Allied Families: The Ancestry of William Henry Moore, 1938

Cynthia Hagar Krusell & Betty Magoun Bates, Marshfield: A Town of Villages 1640-1990, 1990

Miss M.A. Thomas, NEHGS Register, “Deaths and Burials in Marshfield,” 8:192

Justin Winsor (communicated by), NEHGS Register, “Abstracts of the Earliest Wills in the Probate Office, Plymouth,” 6:185

Backus, Mary Elizabeth (Neilson), The New England Ancestry of Dana Converse Backus, 1949,  p 57

Julia Locke Bunce, Some of the Ancestors of Reverend John Selby Frame and His Wife Clara Winchester Dana, 1948, p 299

Robert S Wakefield and Ann Smith Lainhart, Mayflower Families Through Five Generations, Volume 22: Family of William Bradford, GSMD, 2004 

Lysander Salmon Richards, History of Marshfield, 1901

Donald Lines Jacobus, The Waterman Family, Volume I: Descendants of Robert Waterman of Marshfield, Massachusetts, through Seventh Generations, volume 1, 1939

Friday, November 13, 2026

William Holmes circa 1592 to November 1678, of Sandwich, England and Scituate & Marshfield, Mass., and his wife Elizabeth

William Holmes was born in England about 1592, based on his age at death. He came to Plymouth Colony on the Hercules which departed Sandwich, Kent in March 1634/5, as a servant to William Hatch of Sandwich. [NEHGS Register, hereafter NEHGR, 75:219] He is my 10th great-grandfather on my grandfather Arthur Washburn Ellis Davis’ side of the family. 

William was married by about 1637 to a woman named Elizabeth, whose maiden name is not recorded. [Records of the Colony of New Plymouth, hereafter PCR 1:98] Based on her age at death, Elizabeth was born about 1612, making William 20 years her senior. A first marriage for a man in his 40s was unusual, but it is possible their ages at death are not accurate and William was born later. I have not found any indication of Elizabeth being a second wife. 


“Willm Holmes Senior” is in the Scituate section of 1639 list of those who had taken the oath of fidelity.  [PCR,  8:182]  The “senior” does not indicate he had a son William, but was to differentiate him from Lt William Holmes, who was of Duxbury but owned land in Scituate, and was later of Boston. 


William appears in the 1643 Plymouth Colony list of men able to bear arms. [PCR 8:190]. He was admitted freeman on 1 June 1658. [PCR 3:136] He is also in Marshfield sections of 1658 and 29 May 1670 lists of freemen. [PCR 5:277, 8:201]


William was literate as his inventory contained six books [Plymouth County Probate Records 4:1:3] and he signed documents. I don’t find a good deal of public service attributed to William, but he was appointed Marshfield constable in 1665. [PCR 7:122-25] 


William Holmes' signature first column, about halfway down

Elizabeth and William had eight children, all baptized in Scituate Second Church: [approximate birth years from Anderson]

  1. Josiah Holmes, born say 1638, baptized Scituate 27 April 1661 [NEHGR 57:178]; married Duxbury 20 March 1665[/6?] Hannah Samson, daughter of Henry Samson [Anderson 3:1623; Plymouth County Land Records 4:188]
  2. Abraham born  say 1640; baptized Scituate 14 April 1661 [NEHGR 57:178]; married (1) by 1666 Elizabeth Arnold (eldest known child born Marshfield 18 Sept 1666 [Marshfield VR 6]), daughter of Samuel Arnold; married (2) Hingham 19 April 1695 Abigail [—?—] Nichols widow of Ephraim Nichols [Hingham History 2:351; 3:84]
  3. Elizabeth born say 1642; baptized Scituate 20 Oct 1661 [NEHGR 57:178]; living 4 March 1677/8, apparently married [PCPR 4:2]; no further record
  4. Mary born say 1644, baptized Scituate 27 April 1661 [NEHGR 57:178]; married Marshfield 24 Jan 1664[/5?] Thomas Tilden [Marshfield VR 5: Joseph Neal Anc 62-62]
  5. Sarah born say 1646; baptized Scituate 14 April 1661 [NEHGR 57:178]; she married about 1671 Rev. Samuel Arnold and they lived in Rochester [NEHGR 145:374]
  6. Rebecca born say 1646, baptized Scituate 14 April 1661 [NEHGR 57:178]; living 4 March 1677/8, apparently married [PCPR 4:1:2]; no further record 
  7. Israel born say 1650, baptized Scituate 14 April 1661 [NEHGR 57:178]; married Marshfield 24 Nov 1681 Desire (Doty) Sherman [Marshfield VR 16; MD 3:42], daughter of Edward Doty [Anderson 1:573-77; Mayflower Families 11:2:8-10] and widow of William Sherman [Anderson 3:1674; Mayflower Families 4:171-74]; shipwrecked and lost sailing into Plymouth Harbor 24 February 1684 [Deane]
  8. Isaac born say 1653; baptized Scituate 14 April 1661 [NEHGR 57:178]; married Marshfield [worn] April 167[worn] Anne Rowse [Marshfield VR 9], daughter of John Rowse (in her will of 10 Nov 1687, “Annis Rows relict of John Rows late of Marshfeild deceased” included a bequest to “my daughter Anna Holmes.” [Plymouth County Probate Records 1:23])

I descend from Sarah. Her marriage to Samuel Arnold is based on convincing circumstantial evidence as their marriage is not recorded: We know Samuel married a woman named Sarah from his will and other documents; Samuell Arnold Junior and a woman whose last name was Holmes were fined five pounds each at the March 1671/2  court for “committing fornication…before marriage;” Sarah’s brother Abraham married Samuel Arnold’s sister Elizabeth; Sarah is the right age to have married Samuel in 1671; Sarah and Samuel had daughters named Elizabeth and Mary, names of Sarah’s family members. 


Some genealogists believe that Rev. John Holmes of Duxbury was William’s son but evidence is lacking.


William Holmes was one of the Scituate Conihassett Partners of 1646. He later moved his family to nearby Marshfield, where he was perhaps by 1658. [PCR 8:201] That his children were baptized in Scituate in 1661 does not necessarily mean he was living there—he resided in the north Marshfield near the southern part of Scituate served by the Second Church. [Anderson]


On 5 June 1666 “Willam Holmes hath liberty to look out land for the accommodation of his children.” [PCR 4:132]


William Holmes was involved in multiple land transactions. Some of the places he owned land in Scituate are Hoopole Neck, Three-Mile Tract at Accord Pond, Third Cliff, Great Neck, and “the beaches.”

  • The great deed of 1 December 1646 records Timothy Hatherly’s sale of 27/30ths of three quarters of the Conihasset Grant, keeping the quarter part that was originally his own grant. William Holmes purchased one share, a cost of £108. Later these purchasers, or partners, were granted additional Conihasset land. [PCR 12:158]
  • 27 Sept 1655 William Holms declared that he had 1/30th share of Conihasset in which the First Cliff is mentioned, but that it owned it jointly with William Perry; an earlier error attributed it to Holms alone. [Bangs]
  • 28 March 1662 William Holmes chose lot 11 in a Conihasset land division. [Bangs]
  • Undated, John Allen Sr sold his rights in the three-mile tract at Accord Pond to William Holmes “of Marshfield.” [Bangs]
  • 25 March 1662[/?63] William Holmes “of Marshfield” sold half a share in Conihasset undivided land to Joseph Tilden. [Bangs]
  • 22 May 1671 William Holmes conveyed the share in the three-mile tract at Accord Pond that he obtained from John Allin to his son Abraham Holmes. [Bangs]
  • 3 June 1671 William Holmes conveyed one share in the three-mile tract at Accord Pond to his son Josias Holmes. [Bangs]
  • Undated, “William Holmes of Marshfield” deeded to “my son Josiah Holmes of Duxburrow…all my right, title and interest in or to the common and undivided lands of the town of Scituate by virtue of the freemen’s act in surrendering up their power of disposal unto the whole inhabitants of the town of Scituate on the thirteenth of December 1647, I William Holmes being at the time an inhabitant of the town of Scittuate.” [Plymouth County Land Records 4:130]
  • Undated, William Holmes have alienated and sold to John Allen Senior my lot of Marsh lying on the West side of the Great Neck bounded by marsh of Gowin White, to the Gulf Creek. [Bangs]
  • 28 Jan 1694/5 the Conihasset company voted for the choice and taking up of a 20 acre lot as well as a 10 acre lot to each 30th share and lots were drawn. William Holmes: 10 acre lot: 1st; 20 acre lot 26th. [Bangs]

William’s sons sold some of their father’s Scituate land:

  • 26 Dec 1671 Josias Holmes sold one share in the three-mile tract at Accord Pond to Joshua Lincoln of Hingham. [Bangs]
  • 25 March 1671 [1672] Abraham Holmes sold the share in the three-mile tract at Accord Pond that he received from his father William Holmes, to James Whiton of Hingham.
  • Court of Plymouth granted tracts of land to Mr Timothy Hatherly being three miles square and lying in Sittuate by Accord Pond. A few of the men are mentioned by name including William Homes received 1 whole share of the Conihasset land and he was alienating that 1/30th share of land from himself to his son Josias Homes, dated 3 June 1671. Josias Homes sold aforesaid share to Joshua Lincorne for £10 14 shillings on 26 Dec 1671. [Bangs]
  • Land at 3-mile Tract by Accord Pond, Timothy Hatherly alienated 27 parts of the 30 parts to 27 purchasers. John Allinge mentioned in the grand deed to have one whole share alienated unto William Hombes, who then alienated same to his son Abraham Hombes. 22 May 1671. [Bangs]
  • Abraham Hombes alienated the above land at Accord Pond to James Witon of Hingham, acknowledged 25 March 1671. [Bangs]

Other land transactions that refer to William’s land:

  • 13 March 1695 [94/95] John Cowen Jr formerly belonging to a larger lot owned by William Holmes, fol 171 [Bangs]
  • 16 May 1695, land laid out for William Peakes in the right of Mr Tilden’s one acre of land standing in Hooppole Neck swamp, borders land in the right of William Holmes. 
  • Undated, 27th lot of marsh being Joseph Tilden’s on the southwest side of the Great Neck, bounded towards the northwest to Wm Homes his marsh. [Bangs]
  • 12 March 1695 measured 12.5 acres of Holmes’ 25 acre lot now in the possession and occupation of Rodulphus Elmes. [Bangs]
  • Undated, Thomas Ensings 20 acre lot of the first division near a swamp or swampy upland bounds William Holmes’ lot.  [Bangs]
  • Undated, 53 lot of marsh of Jno Whiston lying in Hoopole Neck fresh marsh, bounded by Wm Holmes. [Bangs]
  • 14 March 1695, 6 plus acres of land laid out on the northeasterly side of the Great Swamp and to the northwest ward of William Hollmes, part of that was Major Cudworth’s second division land in the possession of Timothy White. [Bangs]
  • Undated, 52nd lot of marsh of Wm Holmes bounded towards the south to Mr Cudworth’s marsh at Hooppole Neck swamp. [Bangs]
  • 13 April 1695, land laid out for John Barker in the right of John Whetcombe, Lyeth partly in the Great Swamp and adjoins near the westward end of William Holmes’ 25 acre lot. [Bangs]
  • Undated, 26 lot of marsh being William Holmes lying on the west side of the Great Neck bounded to the north to Goyen White’s marsh. [Bangs]
  • 13 March 1695 land laid out on the northwesterly end of William Holmes his 25 acres of the first division, 12.5 ares that Lyeth between the Great Swamp and Hoopowl Neck Cartway. 12.5 acres of land was formerly part of sd Holmes’ 25 acre lot but this part is now claimed and in possession of John Cowing Jr. [Bangs]
  • 24 May 1710 Laid out for William Peackes one acre in the right of William Holmes in the 7th division, 23rd allotment. Land Lyeth in the beaches at two places. [Bangs]

One of the great things about an ancestor being a Conihasset Purchaser is that the company kept detailed records through the years, even mentioning who the original purchaser was by stating it was “in the right of,” so it’s possible to track the ownership of the land over a period of time. There are many such instances that mention land in the right of William Holmes. The Conihasset Company met on 1 March 1649 and William Holmes was one of the signers of document stating that if a purchaser dies, his land would go to his heirs or assigns. [Bangs]


Court involvement of Elizabeth and William:

  • On 4 Sept 1638, “Francis Baver, of Scituate [was] presented for offering to lie with the wife of Willm Holmes, & to abuse her body with uncleanness.” [PCR 1:98]
  • On 7 Sept 1641, “Gowen White, of Scittuate, for his assault upon Willm Holmes, is fined by the Court five shillings.” [PCR 2:24]
  • On 5 April 1642 “Wm Holmes” posted a bond as surety for “John Stockbridg[e] of Scituate.” [PCR 2:38]
  • In 1661 Elizabeth Holmes was accused of being a witch! On 5 March 1660/1 “Dina[h] Silvester, being examined, saith the bear she saw was about a stone’s throw from the highway when she saw it; and being examined and asked what manner of tail the bear had, she said she could not tell, for his head was towards her.” A marginal annotation in record: “This was ordered to be recorded for the clearing of a report about Wm Holmes his wife being accused to be a witch.”  [PCR 3:205, 207] This was a time when witches were thought to be communing with the devil, rather than making magic. I wrote more about this here.
  • William did not abide the slander against his wife: on 7 May 1661 “[c]oncerning the complaint of Willam Holmes, of Marshfield, against Dinah Silvester, for accusing his wife to be a witch, the Court have sentenced, that the said Dinah Silvester shall either be publicly whipped or pay the sum of five pounds to the said William Holmes; or in case she…shall make a public acknowledgement of her fault in the premises, that then she shall bear only the charge the plaintiff hath been at in the prosecution of his said suit; the latter of which was chosen and done by the said Dinah Silvester” on 9 May 1661. [PCR 3:211] Dinah did offer pubic acknowledgement that she wrongly accused Elizabeth. 
  • When William Hatch was prosecuted for his loose speech concerning the government and his contempt for its authority, William Holmes gave deposition against him stating the Hatch [his former master] said “that the warrants sent from the governor were nothing but stincking commissary warrants or attachments  and that the warrants sent in that kynd are no better than commissary court warrants; and that the warrant sent to the constable to Warne him the sd Hatch to appeare at the Court of our Soveraigne lord the Kinge was but a commissary warrant.” Date not stated but likely 1630s. [Pratt]

In his will dated 4 March 1677/8 and proved 25 February 1678/9, “Willam Homes of Marshfeild” bequeathed to “my beloved wife one-third part of all my housing and lands and chattels and moveable estate…during her widowhood, and then I give the aforesaid thirds of my whole estate to my two sons Israell and Isacke, but in case my wife marry I do bequeath her five pounds;” to “my two sons Israell and Isacke and their heirs two-thirds of my whole estate of housing and lands and moveables and chattels;” to “my two sons Josiah and Abraham five shillings each;” to “my daughters Elizabeth, Mary, Sarah and Rebecca twenty shillings apiece;” to “all my grandchildren that are now extant five pounds to be equally distributed amongst them;” “my beloved sons Israell and Isacke to be my executors.” [Plymouth County Probate Records 4:1:3]


William Holmes died 8 November 1678 [date provided in his inventory]. William Holmes, being 86 years old, was buried 9 November 1678.  [Marshfield VR 9; MD 2:181; NEHGR 8:192]


Elizabeth did not remarry. Elizabeth the widow of Wm Holmes died at Marshfield on 17 February 1698[/9?] “in ye 86th year of her age.” [Marshfield VR 19; Mayflower Descendant 5:233]


Sources: 

Samuel Deane, History of Scituate Massachusetts, from its first settlement to 1831, 1831

Harvey Hunter Pratt, Early Planters of Scituate, 1929

Robert Charles Anderson, The Great Migration Begins, 1995

Miss M.A. Thomas, NEHGS Register, “Deaths and Burials in Marshfield, 8:192

Jeremy Dupertuis Bangs, The Seventeenth Century Town Records of Scituate, Massachusetts, Volume Two, 1999

Nathaniel B. Shurtleff and David Pulsifer, eds., Records of the Colony of New Plymouth, in New England, 12 vols.

Judith Broadwell, NEHGS Register, “Genealogical Notes: ”Sarah Holmes, wife of Samuel 2 Arnold identified,” 145:374 (1991):